I say ri-caw-tuh, some say ri-coata, which is stuffed in a Cal-zoan -- unless it's calt-zonay…(and then there's a ri-gut stuffed ca'zone but that's a whole other level of Brooklynese that brings me back to Junior High School...).
I'm digressing before I even start.
However you say it, a ricotta-stuffed calzone is a delicious thing, basically a big, beautiful grilled cheese sandwich oozing sweet milky ricotta and gooey mozzarella, sparked with plenty of pecorino or parmesan. I've loved them ever since I was a kid, and lately I've been eating a lot of them as "research" for an upcoming column and video I'm working on for the Times.
Of course I'd be remiss if my research didn't include a trip to Lucali’s in Carroll Gardens. So I headed over there this week to pick up some tips and techniques from a calzone master, chef/owner Mark Iacono.
Some mighty gorgeous pies come out of Mark’s brick oven, but the calzones are equally special. Tender and soft, the dough retains a lovely chew even with a touch of char from the super-hot oven, and just the right amount of cheese gets all melt-ey and ooze-ey. I took the remains of our practice home, and the calzones were even delicious cold.
(That's Lucali's oven, it can reach about 1000 degrees F.)
One thing I learned for sure—you want to use drier ingredients for a calzone than you might for a pizza. Since a calzone locks in moisture (unlike a pizza where much of the moisture evaporates and condenses), you want to keep wetness to a minimum so you get a properly and thoroughly baked shell with any dreaded sogginess. If you’re using ricotta, give it a really good squeeze (or better yet, strain it in the fridge overnight). And as much as I love runny, fresh, buffalo mozzarella, the denser, cow's milk kind works much better in calzones (look for the stuff wrapped in cellophane rather than balls bobbing in water). Whatever cheeses you’re using, be sure to season them aggressively (lots of black pepper) before sealing up your cheesy, doughy package.
Mark also makes an irresistible dessert calzone, with sweetend ricotta on the inside and swirls of melty nutella (the kind imported from Italy, of course) on the outside, seasoned with sea salt. I came home and made something similar with honeyed ricotta mixed with orange zest and cinnamon on the inside, and powdered sugar and honey on top. Heavenly (there it is, below).
Anyway look for more about calzones in a few weeks in the Times. In the meantime, I'll be trying out different filling combinations (broccoli rabe, olives and parmesan sounds like a good to me), and generally brushing up on my calzone technique -- and pronounciation.

I love them but never made them. I will be making my first tomorrow night!
Posted by: Juicer | 03/16/2012 at 05:19 PM
I'm partial to Marcella Hazan's sfinciuni with mushrooms and cubed ham. Somehow in our household the name for this stuffed pizza has permuted to "stufficino" which is straightforward to pronounce and exactly describes the end product while still sounding like an Italian specialty.
Posted by: Karen | 03/17/2012 at 10:16 AM
Gooey Mozarella and Ricotta are the best stuffings for Calzone.
Posted by: Jenn's ice cream game | 03/19/2012 at 12:59 PM
Can't wait to get my hands on those. Will anxiously be reading the Times until then!
Do you make your own ricotta?
Posted by: Jessie Kanelos | 03/19/2012 at 01:48 PM
Oh man, now I want a calzone real bad!
Posted by: Sarah R | 03/20/2012 at 11:08 AM
Hey Melissa-
Calt-zonay is what I say when I fantasize about my times in Italy! But back to the Upper West Side, and passing by Carmine's yesterday there was a wine tasting AND Calzone sampling. Pretty good but can't wait for the NYTimes recipe. I have a Calzone proposal for you. To build traffic to my blog, I want to do a book give-away. Are you interested offering a signed copy of Cook This Now and perhaps 10 questions answered/and or guest blogging on my site? I barter as well.
Best,
Lauren Simon
Posted by: Laurensplate.wordpress.com | 03/21/2012 at 11:23 AM
Hi Lauren- email me through the bio tab and we can discuss.
Jessie- I have been making my own ricotta and just shot a video of it for the Times, so look out for that!
Posted by: Melissa | 03/22/2012 at 10:34 AM
Salivating over it all! If you can't get to Sicily, there is always delicious Brooklyn!
Posted by: Susan Van Allen | 03/24/2012 at 12:09 AM
Hi Melissa,
I made your pumpkin loaf that you posted in January, but used bananas with dark rum and it was delicious. I was thinking about making it for a party and wanted to bake it in mini muffin cups without the paper cups. Do you think it would work and could I bake it at the same temp and time?
thanks!
Posted by: Vicki | 03/28/2012 at 07:31 AM
Hi Vicki - I think that would work, at the same oven temp. Just check them often for doneness, they will definitely need a lot less time than the load cake. Mini muffins are usually done in about 20 minutes. Good luck!
Posted by: Melissa | 03/28/2012 at 10:44 AM